discount microsoft visual studio to download software tom tom software download download windows 7 ultimate key buy adobe premiere 4 cheap prices discount windows 7 home premium cheap hotel software wholesale discount adobe acrobat 9 standard oem cheap software adobe adobe cs student discount autocad 2010 uninstaller download buy windows 7 system builders benefits to buying oem software bulk email software buy adobe illustrator cs- student discount final cut pro software 2009 buy microsoft office home discount total video converter download software download centre best price for adobe acrobat cheap recording software buy photoshop online cheap windows 7 ultimate software cheap windows excel buy windows 7 phone microsoft to buy google how to download custom texture layer in photoshop elements 8 microsoft points online cheap download acrobat reader 9 buy windows 7 lisence medical billing software prices download remote desktop connection for windows xp where to buy microsoft publisher 2003? microsoft office 2003 student and teacher software download how many downloads are available on buying one copy of adobe cheap adobe software downloadable recording software to buy old versions of software in australia auto part software download microsoft gives employee discount to department of the army buy microsoft office software aperture software cheap cheap microsoft office for army cheap price for windows office 2010 price of Adobe Creative Suite 5 Production Premium buy windows 7 pro download cheap adobe photoshop cs4 best prices download cheap software to copy vhs movies to pc discount microsoft office pro price management software Adobe Creative Suite 5 downloadable discount adobe acrobat Adobe CS5 Production cheap price adobe acrobat 8 standard oem discount microsoft to buy google cheap microsoft word software where to buy microsoft office lowest cost Adobe CS5 Design best cheap video sound software Adobe Creative Suite 5 Design Premium with cheap price Creative Suite 5 Design with cheap price where to buy Adobe Creative Suite 5 Master Collection cost of Adobe Creative Suite 5 Production Premium discount CS5 Production Premium where to buy Adobe CS5 Production online purchase Adobe CS5 Master Collection on line cost of CS5 Web Premium buy Adobe CS5 Production Premium web store Adobe CS5 purchase on line Adobe CS5 Master Collection Adobe Creative Suite 5 Design Premium with cheap price where to buy Adobe CS5 Adobe Creative Suite 5 Master Collection oem buy cheap Adobe CS5 Web Adobe Creative Suite 5 Design Premium oem where to buy Creative Suite 5 Web Premium purchase Adobe Creative Suite 5 Master Collection buy Creative Suite 5 Master oem Creative Suite 5 Web with cheap price purchase Creative Suite 5 Web msn software download windows 7 upgrade cheap Adobe Creative Suite 5 with cheap price where to buy Adobe Creative Suite 5 Master online buy windows 7 oem cheap windows xp dell laptop download map virtual dj 6 buy 2010 ms office buy office 2010 academic microsoft office pro 2007 office 2007 vs 2003 office 2007 remove hidden data adobe hacienda sedona az buy cheep software adobe cs3 serie pocket adobe adobe web where to buy microsoft points win vista defrag microsoft office 2007 slo adobe premiere elements 3 do i need adobe reader adobe air cooler download windows 2000 software best buy windows 7 upgrade cheap copy of windows vista adobe acrobat 9 download cheap adobe dreamweaver cs4 mac microsoft office 2010 discount rate for students microsoft technet standard discount code download pc softwares buy office 2007 home purchase online Adobe CS5 Design Premium windows 7 at sdsu student discount autocad 2010 uninstaller download microsoft home & student 2010 discount buy Adobe CS5 Design online CS5 Design Premium downloadable web store Adobe Creative Suite 5 discount Adobe Creative Suite 5 Web Premium discount on adobe cs software web store Creative Suite 5 Production Adobe Creative Suite 5 Master oem windows 7 college discount download password protection software buy Adobe CS5 Master Collection oem buy office 2007 online software for downloading music educator discount+windows 7 buy Creative Suite 5 Design Premium special offer cheap photoshop software buy online Creative Suite 5 Master Collection download discount windows 7 32 bit buy cheap Adobe Creative Suite 5 Production Premium download adobe dreamweaver cs4 portable windows 7 product key activation buy purchase online Adobe Creative Suite 5 buy Adobe CS5 Production Premium i want to buy a windows 7 pro license key buy photoshop elements 9 Creative Suite 5 Design cheap price windows 7 home premium buy download software sound digital art software downloads cheap adobe design premium cs4 mac norton ghost 15 restore iso download adobe acrobat pro 9 download toorent replica watches bags made in korea louis vuitton cup replica watches waterfall tork pump clock control
Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/frenchman/ in /home/frenchman/ on line 8
French attitudes towards Robespierre?


(asked by Larry from Australia)


Can you please tell us a little more of French attitudes towards Robespierre? Is he generally regarded as a bloodthirsty tyrant or a great liberator these days or is the answer more nuanced than that? There are surprisingly few books about him in English and not that many websites either, given his significance as a political figure. Those resources that do exist seem to give a very incomplete picture of him and it is hard to understand the man and his motivations: in other words, was he an idealist who believed passionately and, ultimately, fanatically, in Liberty, Equality and Fraternity, or a cynical, power-hungry opportunist? Some websites give the impression that he was very protective of his younger siblings growing up and this formed his attitude to the extent that he thought of all of the French citizens as his family and he wanted to “protect” and father them all, whereas other sites give the impression he was an extremely cold and ruthless human being, softly spoken (as opposed to a ranting, table-thumper like Hitler) but extremely dangerous to have as an opponent.

I think it is important to understand as he is the first in the long line of lawyers-turned-politicians that dominate our democratic parliaments today, so I would greatly appreciate in any insights or thoughts you have.


Ok, I will upset a few more people (again…) but while some people have been waiting for their answers for months, Larry asked his just a few days ago and are already finding an answer. Make me interested and that might happen too. ;-) Don’t get me wrong, I don’t find the other questions in my backlog to be uninteresting (well, some are), it’s just that this “first come first serve” policy I have doesn’t work right now. For it to work I should be answering questions every other day or so, and we all know that this won’t happen. So it’s not impossible that the next questions I answer are also handpicked from the vast amount of questions I already got, but not necessarily in their order of arrival.

So… Robespierre

I have to admit that while I find this question to be very interesting I will give a too short and possibly unsatisfying answer. The main reason is that it really requires an historian to give us the subtleties of his personality, somebody who has read his writings and more.

Instead I will just give my personal opinion and try to expand to the general views of the man in France.

First of all, for the few people who don’t know who he was, here is his Wikipedia page (but seriously if you don’t know who he was, what are you doing on this blog?)

The thing we can all agree on concerning Maximilien François Marie Isidore de Robespierre (yep, that’s his full name) is that he may be the most controversial figure in French history.

The way I see him is that he was a guy who got carried away by his “mission” the way it can often happen during revolutions. In other words, I believe that he was a fanatic and not a cynic. Of course, because of that, he made many mistakes and he is the closest to a real full-fledged dictator that France had (not counting Ancien Régime here for obvious reasons, ok, not counting Charles X and Napoleon III either), but on the other hand, I’m not sure France would have become the democracy than it is without him (or it would have taken a much different and much longer route to get there).

I think that most French people who know enough about him have similar views on the guy, and even the Republic itself has a very ambivalent view on him. A telling detail, which may seem insignificant but that is very telling, is the fact that there are very few streets named after him in France (while every city and pretty much every town has its Rue Danton and Rue Mirabeau for example), and every time someone suggests that there should be one in Paris, it’s a huge and unsolvable debate.

So all in all, I think he’s regarded as three things by French people:

  • a bloodthirsty tyrant by some.
  • a great liberator by some others.
  • and both a bloodthirsty tyrant and a great liberator by some more.


If anybody else has an educated opinion about the guy, please feel free to comment.


Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

  7 Responses to “Can you please tell us a little more of French attitudes towards Robespierre?”

  1. “Of course, because of that, he made many mistakes and he is the closest to a real full-fledged dictator that France had (not counting Ancien Régime here for obvious reasons, ok, not counting Charles X and Napoleon III either)”

    Really? Napoleon doesn’t qualify for you? That’s strange.

    • I hesitated including him or not, but I don’t know, while he was an autocratic asshole, he didn’t behave like your usual dictator on many things too (his code of laws and things like that)

  2. Thanks for putting my question in the express lane. I feel embarrassed for all the people who have been waiting longer but I hope that this topic is of general interest to most of this blog’s readership. Yes, the “fanatic versus cynic” debate is really the heart of my question and I guess that question applies to the real motives of many dictators - even Hitler. (Did he really believe all of his own propaganda that the Jews were poisoning German/Aryan culture or were they just a convenient scapegoat/wealthy target?)

    I also find it very interesting that there are many Rue Dantons but very few streets named after Robespierre. As you note, that is very telling. Thanks again. Looking forward to the comments and insights by other readers.

  3. “… the closest to a real full-fledged dictator that France had (not counting Ancien Régime here for obvious reasons…”

    By the way, I guess it is almost a separate question but, very quickly, what do the French think of monarchs like Louis “Sun King” XIV these days? Is he also regarded as a ruthless megalomaniac or do people think he heralded in a short-lived golden age? I have not seen any of them but the French seem to have made a lot of films about him in the last few decades, some examples being “Le Roi Danse”, “Saint-Cyr”, “Vatel”, “Louis:Enfant Roi”, etc.

    • Yes, in some strange turn of history, Louis XIV is considered by many in France as the greatest king France had and other silliness like that.
      I think that it comes from the fact that during his reign France was more or less the undisputed most powerful country in the (Western) world, so people easily forget the constant warring and the nonsense that Versailles was, both putting France close to bankruptcy and causing the Revolution about a century later (and poor Louis XVI took all the blame when he was really not that bad).

      • Yes, I read recently that Louis XIV built/expanded Versailles purely to have all of the other aristocrats close at hand to wait on him, thereby keeping them under close observation and so occupied with pointless rituals that they could not plot against him.

        • Yes, to make a long story short, Louis XIV was crowned king as a kid, and then, there was some sort of revolt among aristocrats to seize power. He had a distrust of many people, especially the nobility because of that, and this is what triggered his idea to have all of his potential “overthrowers” close at hand, busy with vain and useless things instead of politics, which allowed it to control all of France (and put a definite end to feudalism - which was on its way out anyway).

 Leave a Reply



You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.

© 2007-2011 Ask a Frenchman (except for pics & graphics - Logo © 2011 - FB) | Legal Stuff and Privacy Policy Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha