(asked by db from??? Maybe itís the same David B than previously)
(Ö) I feel like there’s enough America bashing for the moment, I’d like to see some France bashing too (although you did say that history books and teaching programs are biased the world over, which is quite true).
Hope you’ll satisfy my request.
(without bashing me, as can happen so often in such online discussions and debates)
Donít worry about being bashed, I donít know why I would do it as your question is very interesting (and is a welcome and healthy change from the ďIím dating a FrenchmanĒ type of questions). And I do American bashing only when necessary, on that topic, the US doesnít come into play, so I donít need to bash them (and if I bash America a lot, itís because ďqui aime bien, ch‚tie bienĒ as we say in France).
That being said, your question is hard to answer as youíre asking my opinion on the thing, and Iím no historian (and if you want simple facts, I guess Wikipedia and other sites can do the work better than me).
So what do I think about the colonization of Algeria and, well, the rest of colonization in general?
I think colonization was unacceptable. I guess I canít develop the issue more. Maybe I can say that I understand it in the context of the 19th Century, but that doesnít make it OK nonetheless (wow, I hadnít use ďnonethelessĒ in years).
And as far as the Algerian war in concerned, same thing. Itís one of the stupidest things France has ever got involved in.
Once again, I understand the logic behind it. Franceís influence and power in the world had been seriously damaged in the wake of WW2, and some people couldnít accept the fact that a territory that they considered as part of France wanting to be independent.
For those who donít know it, contrarily to most of the colonies that were just that, colonies, Algeria had been fully integrated as a part of France, and this is why there was a war there and not for the other colonies (the rest of Africa became independent quite peacefully), Indochina being another issue, and more some sort of epilogue of WW2 as well as a prologue of the Cold War.
For you Americans (no bashing, I promise), itís a bit like Hawaii was asking to be independent. I donít think many Americans would be OK with this.
OK, I admit, the comparison is not exactly the same as native Hawaiians have the same rights as other Americans living in Hawaii if Iím not wrong.
What about if the Navajos proclaimed the independence of Arizona? Maybe itís more similar to what happened in Algeria.
But in the end of the day, this war was unacceptable as well as pretty much everything that was going on in Algeria at the time:
-Despite the fact that Algeria was considered as France, not everybody was equal there: native Algerians didnít have the same rights as European French.
-European French were literally plundering all the riches of the country, and only them would benefit from them.
-Once again, oil was a major issue there, as if Algeria had been incorporated in French territory (and not the rest of the African colonies), itís not only because a lot of European French had moved there (more than a million people at the time of the war, most of them being second or even third generation), itís also because Algeria was the only source of oil France had without having to import.
I donít know if that answers your question. Thereís obviously much more to add to the topic if we go into details, in which I could go if necessary.